![]() |
||
| HTA Home Page | Articles | United States/20th Century | Baseball on the Beach, Sea Birds, 1952-54 | |
|
Baseball on the Beach, Sea Birds, 1952-54
© 2008 Donald J. Mabry
The Jacksonville Beach Sea Birds offer a case study of the rise and fall of a minor league team. The Sea Birds played in 1952, 1953, and 1954 in the venerable Florida State League. The Sea Birds won more than they lost in the three years, coming in second in 1952; thus, they were better than the average minor leagues team and the team also produced some excellent minor leagues players as well as one major league player and manager. Yet, the team disappeared.
Downtown Jacksonville Beach in the early 1950s
Jacksonville's baseball tradition extended back into the 19th century. The Jays played in the Class C South Atlantic League from 1904-10; was renamed the Tarpons for 1911-16; and then the Roses for 1917. World War I interrupted play. In 1921, a new team, the Scouts, played in the Class C Florida State League. They became the Indians in 1922. The Tars played in the Class B Southeastern League in 1926-30 moving to the Class B South Atlantic League from 1938-42 and the Class A South Atlantic League from 1946-1952. In 1953, the team became the Braves and stayed with that affiliation through 1960. Then the team changed names and affiliations again. The Jacksonville Red Caps played in the Negro American League in 1938 and 1941-1942; the city had a very large African-American population. Spring training for Major League Baseball began in Jacksonville in 1888. The Washington Statesmen hosted the Philadelphia Athletics, Brooklyn Dodgers, Cincinnati Reds and Boston Nationals.[3] The Boston Braves (then called the Beaneaters) trained in 1906. The Philadelphia Athletics trained there in 1903, 1914-18; the New York Yankees in 1919-20; the Cincinnati Reds in 1905. The Brooklyn Superbas (Dodgers) trained in 1907-09, the Brooklyn Robins (Dodgers) in 1919-20, 1922; and the Pittsburgh Pirates in 1918.[4] After all, those were the days before Henry Flagler and Henry Plant had opened up Florida south of Jacksonville with railroads. Ironically, Beach Boulevard was built on the right of way of Flagler’s defunct spur line from south Jacksonville to the beach. Jacksonville Beach businessmen cashed in on the area's historic affinity for professional baseball by daring to a ballpark a few blocks south of the Beach Boulevard and fourteen blocks from the ocean. They created the Greater Beaches Stadium, Inc. on October 7, 1949 in anticipation of the grand opening of Beach Boulevard within two months. Stock was issued at $5 a share. The corporation was capitalized at $25,000. Stockholders included Howard A. Prather, Harry Hatcher, Jr., Herbert A. Shelley, F. A. Griffin, W. D. “Pete” Dickinson, H. B. Bradford, Ira D. Sams, H. A. “Pee Wee” Durden, and Martin G. Williams.[5] Prather was mayor; Sams, who owned a laundry and some apartments, would be. Shelley owned two game sites on the Boardwalk and directed the Beaches Chamber of Commerce. Griffin had his own amusement park on the Boardwalk. Williams and Dickinson owned buildings which houses different concessions. Prather, a pharmacist, owned a drug store and building across the street. He was the president of the corporation; Hatcher, an accountant who also had a Boardwalk business, was vice president. Shelley was secretary. Ownership appears to have been widespread. By March 2, 1950, construction crews were hustled to the deadline of having the ballpark ready for the March 27th exhibition game between the Roanoke Red Sox and the St. Augustine Saints. The Beaches News & Advertiser reported on November 17, 1950, that the Beaches might get a Florida State League team in 1951. By early February, 1951, the Corporation was trying to sell it to the City of Jacksonville Beach. Although there was opposition, the Corporation prevailed. Many stockholders were also city government officials, a fact which made it easier for the government to buy the assets. Few, if any, made a profit. It was a civic gesture. The corporate owners demonstrated that the ballpark was more than a pipedream and got the city government to agree. [6] The city government did better. The Chicago Cubs sent three farm teams to use the stadium in 1951. On April 3, 1951, the Greensboro Patriots and the Grand Rapids Jets played an exhibition night game. Tickets cost seventy-five cents for adults and thirty-five cents for children. The Des Moines, Iowa Bruins team arrived in early April for six days. The Rutherford County [Spindale , NC] Owls of the Western Carolina League joined their fellow Cubs’ affiliates. City officials hoped to have two female baseball teams in May. In mid-November, 1951, Mayor Sams, Prather, H. B. Bradford, Harry Hatcher, Jr. met with officials of Florida State League and a committee from St. Augustine with idea of creating teams in both cities. The previous St. Augustine Saints of 1950 had become the Cocoa Indians. For scheduling purposes, the league wanted an even number of teams. In late November, 1951 the city was engaged in “office negotiations with the St Louis Browns in hopes that several of its farm teams would do Spring training in 1952. In August, 1952, Chamber of Commerce and city officials also pursued the possibility of the Boston Braves in establishing a minor league training camp in 1953 even though the Sea Birds were using the Municipal Stadium.” Chamber officials estimated that the Braves’ organization would bring 240 players and 250 scouts, trainers, wives, reporters, and fans to the beaches for five to six weeks and would pump $200,00 into the economy.[7]
Photo
by Don Keller Looking North Along
The Boardwalk
The owners hired Thadford Leon Treadway, a former New York Giants player who had become a manager of minor league teams, to create the Sea Birds. Red, as he was known, was born on April 28, 1920 on Crabtree Creek near Athalone, North Carolina into a very poor family. In 1932, the family moved to Marion, North Carolina where he got his first shoes because the family fortunes had improved slightly. By age thirteen, in 1934, he was playing semi-pro baseball in the Tri-County Textile League as a pitcher and a catcher. As he told it, he rented a mule for 10 cents to get to his games. The textile mill gave him a dozen pairs of sox which he sold for a penny each so he netted two cents from each trip, not much money even then but something.
Treadway moved down to the Class AAA Newark Bears of the International League in 1946 with the end of the war and the return of veterans who had been Giants,. He left the team before playing against the Montreal Royals which Jackie Robinson had joined that year.[10] In 1948, he starred on the Des Moines, Iowa Bruins in the Class A Western League. He played in the Caribbean League, managing the Panama Refresqueros de Spur Cola. On the Spur Colas were Negro League players Pat Scantlebury and Leon Kellman. This winter league employed both locals and Americans, including future television star Chuck Conners of Cuba’s Almendares Scorpions. Along the way, Treadway and Conners roomed together.[11] In February, 1949, he starred in the first Caribbean World Series, batting .352 and getting the first hit. The teams—Panama, Cuba, Venezuela, Puerto Rico—featured players of different races. In 1951, he worked as a player-manager for the Suffolk, Virgin Goobers in the Class D Virginia League. Eventually, he became a minor league manager-player. Before creating the Sea Birds, he managed and played for the Suffolk, Virginia Goobers in the Class D Virginia League.[12] There he signed Bobby Trump, the most popular, versatile and colorful Sea Bird.[13] He saw Trump playing high school baseball at Suffolk High as a pitcher and a catcher. Treadway was managing the Suffolk, Virginia professional team in the Virginia League. Suffolk was the home of Planters Peanuts and Treadway and other baseball players worked in the peanut industry as an inspector during the off season. Later, he was able to get jobs in the industry for some Sea Birds jobs when he managed that team. Treadway told the eighteen-year-old Trump on March 4, 1952 to be ready to be transported to Florida by car later that month to begin training. Trump was born on June 19, 1933 in Suffolk, Virginia. Jacksonville, Florida sports columnist Joe Livingston in 1953 said Trump had been courted by the Cleveland Indians organization but Treadway had convinced him to go with the other Virginians. The collapse of the Virginia League and the Goobers freed Treadway and some other league players to head south to Jacksonville Beach. Experienced players such as player-manager of the Emporia Rebels Hal Martin and player-manager of the Edenton Colonials “Gashouse” Parker and others followed him to Florida. Treadway and Trump were the only two who would play both the 1952 and 1953 seasons. Minor league players came and went. Some moved up to higher leagues; some quit; some were released; and some were injured. Pay was meager and the season was only five months long. Scrabbling for income for the rest of the year was tiring. Marriage and children encouraged these young men to find steady, better-paying employment. Treadway was the role model for the club. His batting average in 1952 was .357 with 2 home runs, 65 RBIs, the best on the team. In 1953, it was .365 and one home run with 83 RBIs. Trump would be the most versatile and colorful member in those two years. Of course Treadway recruited more players than he would eventually use on the sixteen-man team. Florida State League rules not only stipulated the number of players on a team roster but also that no more than four (4) could be veterans, that is, had played professional ball for three or more years. Treadway was a player manager so he could only recruit three veterans.[14] Treadway assembled his team, a mixture of veterans[15] and rookies. He held a tryout camp in early March in conjunction with the Cincinnati Reds.[16] As of the April 14, 1952 season opener, the team was: Lonnie Francis (outfield), Hal Martin (outfield-infield), Harmon Young (3B), Red Treadway (outfield, manager), Wally Nolan (2B), Bill Robertson (C), Tom Mills (P), Eddie Celardo (C), Dave McCrickard (P), Alton Doyle (P), Buddy Spindler (SS), Joe Angel (P), Bill Alexander (P), Joe Johnson (P), Bill Herman (P), Bobby Trump (C), Bob Phillips (P), Ray Mieszkowski (1B), Buster Kinard (outfield), Bill Langston (P), Gas House Parker (1B), and Shorty Long (SS). Langston, Parker, Long were released shortly after the photograph was taken. Some were traded. The players Treadway assembled last year for spring training cost the owners $525 but the owners later sold two for $800. By May 1, 1952, there were 16 on the team.
Life was pleasant at the beach. Players roomed and ate in different places in Jacksonville Beach. For example, Bobby Trump and David McCrickard lived above the Bamboo Bar in the heart of downtown which was also the entertainment district. Some lived in the Travelrite Motel very close to the ball park and ate in its restaurant, the Travelrite Drive-In. Others stayed in rooming houses or furnished apartments, both of which were plentiful in the resort community. The Treadways, including their daughter Laura, enjoyed a house in Atlantic Beach. Restaurants often gave them discounts, helping these youngsters who earned very little money in the five months they were in town. They did, of course, enjoy beach life, including the young women who lived or visited at the beach. Konkoleski and some of his teammates in 1954 lived in two-storey frame houses so common in Jacksonville Beach.
The schedule was grueling. For example, in May the Birds played at home on 15 times in 31 days, going on the road the other nights, traveling as much as 161 miles on two-lane roads.[18] In the first week of the 1952 season, Hal Martin played first base until John Hudzik returned and then moved to left field. Ray Panzo, a rookie from Richmond, was signed to play Shortstop. For their first game, they traveled 159 miles on two lane roads to Cocoa for a Monday night game. Then the team returned home to open the home season against St. Augustine which it beat 25-4 before 1,395 fans. Joe Angel pitched in Cocoa and Tom Mills at home. Harmon Young demonstrated his power by hitting a home run. In the Cocoa game, Treadway began the search for the perfect batting lineup. He relied upon men he had brought from the Virginia League: Nolan, Treadway, Kinard, Martin, Robertson, and Young, Meiszkowski, Joe Angel, and Francis. As the season progressed, Treadway adjusted the roster. John Hudzik, who played in the Class C Middle-Atlantic League in 1951, joined the Sea Birds the morning of the first game. Bobby Trump, the most versatile of the Sea Birds did well in the first week; he got a single and a double in the Birds’ first home game against Sanford. That week, he went to the plate 20 times and got 8 hits for a .400 average. Two were doubles. He had four RBIs and a stolen base to his credit. During the course of the summer, Trump played shortstop, second base, outfield, and warmed up in the bullpen in case he had to pitch in relief. By
July 4, 1952, Mills, Angel, and Herman all had thrown no-hitters. Mills threw a
no-hitter against Cocoa for his 19th victory in a 4-0 ballgame.
Thomas “Iron Man” Mills was a 20 year-old, from Geneva, New York who had three
years of professional baseball experience in Lockport, Pennsylvania in the
Class C Middle Atlantic States League.
The Birds were surprisingly successful. The Florida State League split the season in half with the winner of the first half playing the winner of the second half for the pennant. The Birds finished 2nd in the first half of 1952. At the end of the 1952 season during the first playoff game, Bobby Trump demonstrated his amazing versatility in a season-ending game against the Daytona Beach Islanders. For the first seven innings, he played a different position. Had the centerfielder not injured himself while running the bases and Trump had to take his place, the youngster would have completed his grand tour. The game lasted 11 innings; the Birds notched a 7-6 victory. The Birds finished the 1952 season with a 80-56 record, finishing second in the league behind Palatka. In the playoffs, the team finished second. Treadway had acquired a considerable amount of talent for the expansion team. Tom Mills enjoyed a 27-7 pitching record. Joe Angel won 19 and lost 11. Bill Herman went 16-15. Dave McCrickard won 12 and lost 13. These four were the only one who managed to win ten or more games. The best sluggers were Treadway (.357), followed by Hal Martin (.330), Buster Kinard (.314), and Bill Robertson (.300). Floyd Clift hit .333 but he was not on the roster for the entire season.
Nevertheless, the Birds had only drawn 23,210 people at home and lost money. Were it not for Jackson and Cowart buying the team and investing $50,000, the team would have closed after the 1952 season. Both loved baseball and attended the home games, sitting behind the dugout, even though they did not live on the beach. Jackson often brought his very young son, dressing him in a Sea Birds uniform. Treadway created a new team. He signed five rookies and was working on more. He and Young would be the only two “veterans” returning; the League had halved the number allowable. Trump was so good that his return was a cinch. The 1953 Birds would be a quite different but weaker team at the beginning of the season. Florida State League rules in 1953 only allowed two (2) players with three or more year’s experience. Gone were Robertson who went to Class A Williamsport of the Eastern League; Tom Mills who went to Class A Jacksonville but was drafted into the Army; Bill Herman who had to leave because he became a veteran and went to Class B Portsmouth of the Piedmont League; and Buster Kinard who retired. Initially
before the final sorting out, the roster was: Pitchers: Ray Britt, Dave Whitten, John Martin, Ed
Paruch, Joe Angel, Jack Hazen, Bob Kitchen, Howie Rosenfelter, and Vivan
Wright. Catchers: Bobby Trump, John
Richard. Outfielders: Otho Kortz, Red Treadway, Clyde Briggs, and Dick Epps.
Infield: Pat Vastano (SS), Tommy West (2B), Jim Foster (2B) who played in 1949
and 1950 with Gainesville, Harmon Young (3B). Utility: Bob Duncan. There were
two bat boys, Ron Wingate and John Mead.
Some of the players were fresh out of local
colleges, a move that would increase the interest of fans. One was the
Pensacola native, Harold “Herky” Payne (pictured below). Quarterback Payne threw a touchdown pass for Tennessee’s score in its
20-14 victory over Texas in the 1951 Cotton Bowl. Tennessee became national
champions for the first time. Famous for
football, he was also the first All-American baseball player in the history of
the University of Tennessee. He earned second-team honors from the American
Baseball Coaches Association after helping the Volunteers reach the 1951
College World Series. The second baseman hit .362 that year, with 17 hits,
three home runs and 12 RBIs. He was drafted by the Pittsburgh Steelers in 1952
but did not make the team. So he turned to baseball. Another was Jack Hazen who pitched 9-1 for the University of Florida in 1952. Paul Florence tried to sign him to a Cincinnati Reds Class B farm team Burlington [Iowa] Flints but Treadway talked him into playing for the Birds. Jack and his brother owned a 1,000 acre farm in Brooker, Florida near Gainesville, a farm that supported four families. Jack did not want to leave his brother in a lurch by going to Iowa. Instead, he stayed in Florida and gave his brother half his baseball salary and his brother gave him half the farm profits. Hazen said Class D Florida State League ball and collegiate ball were similar. Hazen, before July 21, 1953, went on the inactive list because he had to return to his farm. By the second half of the season, the lineup had changed. Sid Hartfield and Herky Payne were in the outfield. Warren Saye was catching while Trump pitched a 6-5 victory over the Leesburg on “Trump Night,“ the first game of the 2nd half of the season. Fans loved seeing the teenager teach the “older” guys a lesson. Besides, he was such an affable young man.
The 1953 season did not go well even though there were stellar performances. On April 13, 1953, the Birds opened their season in Palatka and returned to the beach the next night to beat the Leesburg Lakers with Britt pitching. Britt was a strong pitcher who could throw no-hitters. In the All-Star game, the Sea Birds placed Joe Angel, Red Foster, Red Treadway, Bob Kitchen, and Bobby Trump. However, the Birds went 68-65 and finished 5th. Treadway went through 13 pitchers and only three had double-digit records: Joe Angel 28-10, Ray Britt 14-7, and Bob Kitchen 10-14. Of the 25 other players who were on the roster that year, only three hit .300 or above: Treadway (.365), Clyde Briggs (.350), and Jim Foster (.301). Too few attended. The 17,785 patrons were considerably less than the year before. Without paying customers who bought concessions and souvenirs, the team did not generate enough income to cover costs. This was true even though as a percentage of its population base it drew better than Jacksonville but, of course, Jacksonville had a much larger population as well as Hank Aaron. Players at the beach, such as Britt, Trump, and Treadway, and Angel, could play excellent baseball but they could not generate the excitement that Aaron did twenty miles west as he dominated the hitting in the South Atlantic League, playing for the Jacksonville Braves. “Aaron delivered a dominating performance, leading the league in runs (115), hits (208), RBI (125) and batting average (.362). The display of offense captured the league's MVP honor.” Attendance increased dramatically because Jacksonville was integrating its team with Aaron, Felix Mantilla, and Horace Garner and Aaron was so outstanding. African American attendance skyrocket but also those of whites. One solution to the attendance problem at the beach was to hire some black players but that was not to be. Hank Aaron said that the Birds tried to put black players on the team but the local chamber of commerce said no. Herb Shelley, Secretary of the Chamber, said “No race is involved in it. It’s just that patrons of the team felt they would rather have an all-white team.” City officials and the American Legion also opposed such a move.[20] By August, owners Jackson and Cowart began talking of shedding their $50,000 losses by pulling out; they demanded concessions from Jacksonville Beach by November 1, 1953. To wit, they wanted a rent-free stadium, utilities, $20,000 worth of advance ticket sales, and 500 season tickets at $40 each ($20,000). Al Burt, a Jacksonville sports writer who was also the team’s scorekeeper, said the biggest problem was attendance and he thought the current attendance was probably the ceiling. An agreement with a major league team might help stabilize the team financially. He thought having a full-time desk man who focused on the problems, as man such as Treadway, might solve the problem. Treadway moved to the Fitzgerald, Georgia team, however.[21] Trump was released on February 24, 1954.[22] The rest either went to another team or gave up the dream. On March 18, 1954, the City of Jacksonville Beach helped the Seabirds Baseball Club by leasing the stadium from April 15th to September 15th for one dollar ($1); agreed to maintain the field and fence; provide police protection; and provide an estimated 65,000 KWH of electricity at the very low rate of two cents a KWH which would total $1,300. The Club would have all rights to advertisements on billboards and the fence. The City, for its part, could use the Stadium when the baseball team had no scheduled game. So, the City had decided to make the 1954 season attractive to owners and a major league team. The Cleveland Indian kept the Sea Birds alive for another year as one of its farm teams but changed the personnel of the team, bringing Spurgeon Ferdinand “Spud” Chandler to coach and a new set of players except for Briggs and West. Briggs had hit .350 with 55 RBIs and one home run in 1953; he would hit .355 with 39 RBIs and 3 home runs in 1954. West hit .243 with 6 RBIs in 1953 and improved to .307 with 70 RBIs and a home run in 1954. The Jacksonville Sea Birds Baseball Club was headed by Jackson with Cowart as vice president and Lewis Matlin as business manager. Chandler
was a well-known in baseball circles and has been nominated for the Baseball
Hall of Fame.[23]
He played 11 years with the New York Yankees (1937-47) with a pitching record
of 109-43 with a 2.83 ERA. He was the only Yankee pitcher to be named the
American League’s Most Valuable Player. He served in WWII. He played in 1946,
going 20-8 with a 2.10 ERA. However, arm surgery failed to solve the problem
that developed and he was released from the Yankees in 1948. He would serve as
a scout and manager for the Cleveland Indians, Yankees, Kansas City Athletics,
and Minnesota Twins. After the Sea Birds stint, Chandler was manager of the
Spartanburg Peaches of the Class B Tri-State League in 1955, and a coach for
the Kansas City Athletics in 1957-1958.[24] The home schedule began for the first half on April 12 and ended on June 20 for 34 games. The second half began June 24 and ended August 30 for 35 games. The road schedule began April 13 and ended on June 18 for 35 games and June 21 through August 28 for the 35-game second season. In total, it was supposed to be a 140 game season. Source: Deane's Studio and Ray Konkoleski 1954 Team Among the players in the 1954 team photo were the following. The middle bat boy was Frank Chandler, the son of Spurgeon Chandler. Kneeling are Lou Matlin, business manager, unknown player, Roy Nixon, Bill Dashner, Tommy West, Lyn Henry, unknown person. Standing in the first row are Julian Jackson (co-owner), unknown player, Roy Chambers, unknown player, Spud Chandler, Ray Konkoleski, Russ Nixon, and T. F. Cowart (co-owner). In the row, Allen Myers is on the extreme right. People in the photo were identified by Ray Konkoleski and by comparing various photos.
Konkoleski remembers his year with Jacksonville Beach fondly. He was given a $1,500 signing bonus collectible at $500 a month. His salary was $175 a month. When the team traveled, the players received $1.75 a day for meals and owner Jackson matched it. Restaurants often gave them a discount. They lived in two-story frame houses, common to the beach, usually renting rooms. Chandler, like Treadway, was like a father to the players who were, for the most part, considerably younger than he. Both managers were experienced Major League Baseball players and minor league managers/coaches. They were married men with families; most of the players were bachelors. Chandler demanded that they not get sun burned, fining any who did, but they could frequent the Boardwalk and other locales. Spring training was in Daytona Beach, home of their arch rivals, the Islanders whose fans harassed the Birds on and off the field. Konkoleski never lost a game against Daytona, giving the Birds great satisfaction. To these young men, being on a team with other like-minded young men, living on a beach, and traveling was as much fun as playing professional baseball. In the early 1950s, when the Unites States was not as prosperous nor as well-organized at it became in the twenty-first century, life held frequent surprises and serendipitous events. Once, when the team bus broke down, the players piled into a pickup truck to get to the game.
What happened to the baseball facilities? City Manager Wilson Wingate worked with Joe O'Toole of the Pittsburgh Pirate organization to locate the Pirates’ minor league training facilities in Jacksonville. Beach.[26] The city built four baseball diamonds just south of the Jacksonville Beach baseball stadium. Seventeen teams trained between 1957 and 1961. In 1957, the Beaumont Texas Pirates of the Class B Big State League, the Clinton Iowa Pirates of the Class D Midwest League, the Columbus Ohio Jets of the Class AAA International League, the Grand Forks, North Dakota Chiefs of the Class C Northern League, the Jamestown, New York Falcons of the Class D New York-Pennsylvania League, and the Lincoln, Nebraska Chiefs of the Class A Western League. Clinton, Columbus, Grand Forks, and Lincoln were joined in 1958 by the Salt Lake City, Utah Bees of the Class AAA Pacific Coast League and the San Angelo, Texas Pirates of the Class C Sophomore League. In 1959, Columbus, Grand Forks, Lincoln, Salt Lake City, and San Angelo were joined by the Class D Dubuque, Iowa Pirates of the Midwest League, the Idaho Falls, Idaho Russets of the Class C Pioneer League, the Wilson, North Carolina Tobs of the Class B Carolina League, and the Columbus, Georgia Pirates of the Class A South Atlantic League. Columbus, Grand Forks, Lincoln, Salt Lake City, San Angelo, and Dubuque were joined in 1960 by the Asheville, North Carolina Tourists of the Class A South Atlantic League, the Burlington, Iowa Bees of the Class B Illinois-Iowa-Illinois League, the Hobbs, New Mexico Pirates of the Class D Sophomore League, and the Savannah, Georgia Pirates of the Class A South Atlantic League. In the last year, 1961, only four teams trained there: Asheville, Burlington, Hobbs, and the Batavia, New York Pirates of the Class D New York-Pennsylvania League. These teams included African American players to the beach. The Beaches were not hospitable to African Americans so there were no facilities available for the black minor league baseball players at the beaches. Wingate’s son, Ron, remembers hearing discussions regarding this problem. Housing was accomplished by farming them out to “The Hill,” a black section of Jacksonville Beach a few blocks east of the station. Strickland’s Restaurant, a very popular eatery more than a mile north, added a back room in which African Americans could eat and be served by fellow African Americans. [27]
The Pirates stayed three years and left but the Beaches benefited. The Pirates organization infused money into the local economy while undermining some of the segregation practices as black and white men played together. After they left, the facilities plus some other acreage were converted to a golf course, Wingate Park with two adult softball fields, two T-Ball fields, two little major league” fields, and a girl’s softball field, and a police building.[28] Why was a community based on entertainment unable to sustain a professional baseball team? The Beaches permanent population in 1950 was less than 11,000. Daytona Beach, which still has a Florida State League team, has 30,000 inhabitants and no big city nearby. Before television, small towns far from big cities could sustain a team, but the Beaches did not meet these conditions. Even though the Beaches grew in the early fifties, supporting a Class D team was impossible. Jacksonville residents could attend the games of the Class A Jacksonville Tars/Braves;[29] why drive twenty miles to see a lesser team? The Birds could not compete against Hank Aaron in 1953 or the Braves in 1954 which also finished first in the league but came in second in the league finals. Even with Russ Nixon playing very well in 1954, the beach team could not compete against the Braves. The city fathers, especially the group which built the stadium and attracted the team, may have assumed that baseball games would be an added tourist attraction in addition those on the Boardwalk and the Jacksonville Beach entertainment district. The city fathers depended upon tourist spending because most were in the hospitality business. We now know that a baseball team at the Beaches could not be profitable or draw people to the beach communities. They misjudged business conditions. Air conditioning in homes kept people inside. The number of air conditioner units, window or central, grew in the early 1950s. In 1950, the nation manufactured 194,000 room air conditioners; in 1955, 1,283,000.[30] The key reason was television. In 1950, 3,875,000 homes had television; by 1955, 30,700,000 did.[31] People chose to watch TV programs, including sports, at home. Minor league teams and leagues were disappearing because of the preference for television and watching major league teams or a higher level minor league team. The major leagues hurt the minor league teams in two ways. First, they expanded the American and National Leagues by absorbing some of the most important and successful minor league teams. Second, they created a farm club system, spending money to insure that the majors would have the players they wanted. This had the effect of orphaning those teams not connected to a major league club’s system. In short, lower-level professional baseball became serious business. By 1960, there were 135 teams in 20 leagues. By 1963, national attendance had dropped from 42 million to less than 10 million.[32] The Sea Birds never solved the attendance problem. Giving away tickets, performing stunts, and special events failed to create an audience that could sustain the team. As the chart below demonstrates, the average crowd never approached three hundred and fifty persons.
The Sea Birds team was just a small episode in the fundamental change in American baseball, a change that made professional baseball a commercial product seen largely on television and not in small ballparks throughout the nation. Professional baseball became a vehicle for giant corporations to advertise their wares on regional and national television. To facilitate making professional baseball a commodity as well as an advertising vehicle, the leagues were reduced in number and categorized into higher levels. Gone were Classes B, C, and D as well as some teams at high levels. Major League Baseball expanded but it was corporate not everyman's baseball. The
Sea Birds may have been a footnote in professional baseball history but the team
was fun while it lasted. Young men got a chance to see how well they could
compete. Some were able to play for other minor league teams, enjoying the
thrill. Russ Nixon made a successful career in Major League Baseball. Treadway
and Chandler were able to shape and inspire young men. Fans saw some good
players and some great games and have fun. And isn’t that what the sport is
about?
By Don Mabry
[1] John Thorn and Pete Palmer, Total Baseball. (NY, Warner Book, 1989), p. 584 assert that, in the 1949-1963 period, the number of leagues dropped from 59 to 18 and attendance went from 42 million to less than 10 million. [2] Beaches is used to mean the communities and towns of Atlantic Beach, Neptune Beach, Jacksonville Beach, Ponte Vedra Beach, Palm Valley, and Mayport, all of which are on the northern end of the barrier island off the coast of Jacksonville, Florida. Although disparate in many ways, they were a cohesive unit in the 1950s. See my World's Finest Beach at http://tinyurl.com/5kdkb3. [3] “Jacksonville Baseball History, “ http://jacksonville.suns.milb.com/about/page.jsp?ymd=20070103&content_id=150375&vkey=about_t564&fext=.jsp&sid=t564 [4] Baseball Almanac, http://www.baseball-almanac.com/teams/springtrainingsites-nl.shtml [5] The corporation ended on April 13, 1956 by proclamation. [6] Ocean Beach Reporter, Friday February 9, 1951. [7] Chamber of Commerce Newsletter, March 2, 1950; Chamber of Commerce Newsletter, III, 14 (November 15, 1951); Chamber of Commerce Newsletter, III:6 (March 29, 1951); Chamber of Commerce Newsletter, III:6 (March 29, 1951); [8] Some of the players lived in the Travelrite although Bobby Trump and David McCrickard lived above a downtown bar. Some ate in the Travelrite Drive-In Restaurant. They got a deal because the business manager in 1952 was Harry Hatcher, Jr. Hatcher became a manager of a Gainesville drug store in 1953. He was replaced by Mrs. Vivian Ropson [now Breckner]. She wrote the column “The Bird Brain” in the Sea Birds program. The Treadways and the Chandlers lived in Atlantic Beach. [9] Now Barton College. [10] Jules Tygiel, Baseball’s Great Experiment: Jackie Robinson and His Legacy, pp. 120-121, says “Treadway of the Newark Bears refused to play against Jackie Robinson in 1946 (a Sunday double header). League officials said he couldn’t find an apartment in Newark and that he opted to play in the Mexican League. A short time later, he asked to be sent to the segregated South Atlantic League.” Bruce Adelson, Brushing Back Jim Crow: The Integration of Minor-league Baseball in the American South. University of Virginia Press, 1999, p. 68 perpetuates the story. Three years later, Treadway was the manager-player of a racially integrated team and played against racially integrated teams in the Caribbean League, including Cuba’s Almendares Scorpions pictured below.
[11] Chuck Conners, according to the Web site http://www.armchairgm.com/Baseball_Notebook:_Jim_Abbott_and_Chuck_Connors_Facts (retrieved July 3, 2008) was born Kevin Joseph Aloysius Connors on April 21, 1921. He played in the National Basketball Association, was drafted but never played in the National Football League, and made a reputation playing professional baseball, mostly in the minor leagues. His play for the Los Angeles Angels provided the entry into show business. [12] After he managed the Sea Birds in 1953 and 1954, he moved on. Treadway was manager of the Fitzgerald Red Legs of the Class D Georgia-Florida League in 1954, Duluth Dukes of the Class C Northern League in 1955 (beginning of season), Ogden Reds of the Class C Pioneer League in 1955 (end of season), and Fitzgerald A's of the Class D Georgia-Florida League in 1956. Treadway, as a New York Giant, inspired a poem by Saul Bennett: Leon Treadway Enters Heaven I watched in the War my beloved Giant journeyman outfielder no one knows today, Leon (Red) Treadway, explode from first on a swat into a Polo Grounds gap, round third in an arc so wide I feared at 8 for his run that would knot the game. When his slide eluded the Nazi's lunge at the plate I felt nothing, ever, again, might get me. [13] Trump was young, handsome, humorous, and talented. He was a credible player at any position. He was willing to engage in the various promotional stunts dreamed up by management to boost attendance. He also came to know some local people including girls from the high school. Ron Wingate, one of the bat boys in 1953, remarked that Trump was idolized by young boys because he seemed to have it all. [14] An example of roster fluctuations can be found in Beaches News & Advertiser, April 3, 1952. Floyd Clift was moved from 1B TO RF; Lyn Karp, a newcomer on option from Cincinnati, was sent to 1B. Steve Korfonta, a new player, was assigned to 2B; Harmon Young went to 3B; Nibaldo Ugarde played SS, and Ernie Clark, said to be owned by the Cincinnati Reds, was signed as a new pitcher. [15] Veterans included those who had played professional baseball but the Florida State League classified a veteran as a person who had played three years or more. [16] Beach News, Thurs, March 6, 1952. [17] Beaches News & Advertiser, April 3, 1952. [18] Beaches News & Advertiser, 1952. [19] Teammates nicknamed him “Apple Pie” after a young woman rewarded him with one of her apple pies. [20] Hank Aaron with Lonnie Wheeler, I Had A Hammer: The Hank Aaron Story. NY: HarperCollins, 1991, p 51. Bruce Adelson, Brushing Back Jim Crow: The Integration of Minor-league Baseball in the American South. University of Virginia Press, 1999, p. 68. [21] In 1955, he managed the Duluth [MN] Dukes of the Class C Northern League in the first half of the season and the Ogden Reds of the Class C Pioneer League at the end of the season. Then he returned to Georgia to manage the Fitzgerald A's of the Class D Georgia-Florida League in 1956. By 1960, he moved to the Atlanta area and took a non-baseball job and died there in 1994. [22] Trump was drafted in November, 1953 and entered the U. S. Army for two years where he continued to play baseball, including in Okinawa. He went back to Virginia and graduated from the Norfolk Division of the College of William & Mary in Williamsburg, Virginia which became Old Dominion University. He could not play college baseball as he would have liked because he had been a professional. He worked for Pepsi Cola before joining a bank (now the Sun Trust chain) from which he retired. [23] Kevin M. McCarthy. Baseball in Florida. Sarasota, FL: Pineapple Press, 1996, 112-113. [24] His obituary of January 11, 1990 in the St. Petersburg Times [Florida] says he moved to the St. Petersburg area in 1954. Chandler was born in Commerce in Franklin County, Georgia. Ty Cobb was also born in Franklin County. [25] Professional Baseball Player Database Version 6.0 1995-2005 Old-Time Data Inc. [26] Lowenfish, Lee, Branch Rickey : Baseball's Ferocious Gentleman. Lincoln : University of Nebraska Press, 2007, p. 512 notes that, in the early fall of 1951, Branch Rickey of the Pirates had an instructional league for promising young players in Deland, Florida. Nearly 60 minor leaguers plus 4 young members of the Pirates were trained. [27] Conversations and electronic mail with Ron Wingate and Tom Ravoo, who worked at Strickland’s. Ravoo worked as a part-time busboy. The players were served by black female kitchen workers but Ravoo and the other busboys had no trouble working that dining room because they enjoyed seeing professional baseball player. Ravoo’s comments are posted on beacheshistory.wetpaint.com at 3:14 PM EST, February 22 2008 under RE: Pittsburgh Pirates at the beach. Data on the Pirates' farm teams was supplied by Kevin Saldana of Baseball Guru, http://baseballguru.com/ksaldana/. [28] Bill Foley, “Spring training dream endures in N. Florida,” Florida Times-Union, July 30, 1997. [29] The team was renamed the Braves in 1953 when it affiliated with the Milwaukee Braves. [30] The Statistical History of the United States: From Colonial Times to the Present (New York, Basic Books, 1976), pp. 694-695 [31] The Statistical History of the United States: From Colonial Times to the Present (New York, Basic Books, 1976), p.795. [32] John Thorn and Pete Palmer, Total Baseball. (NY, Warner Book, 1989), p. 584. Sources: Note: I am deeply indebted to the family of Bobby L. Trump, Sr., his wife Joyce, his son Bobby L. Trump, Jr. and his son-in-law, Rich Hensler for supplying me with newspaper clippings, photographs, and details of his life.Trump died on December 14, 2008, months after this article was written. I am also indebted to Laura Treadway de Martino, daughter of Leon “Red” Treadway. Ray and Lois Konkoleski were generous with materials and stories about his career. The Beaches Area Historical Society, especially archivist Taryn Rodríquez-Boette, was helpful. In addition, the following individuals, most of whom were teenagers in the early 1950s at the beaches, corresponded with me on Sea Bird history: Austin Smith, Ron Wingate, Terry Jones, Harley Henry, Paul Marino, Tom Ravoo, and Harley Henry. Dick Bussard, a former editor of the Ocean Beach Reporter, Mike McCann, an informed baseball Webmaster, Clint Chafin, Jeff Howell, and Edwin Ellis helped as well.
Beaches
News
Burt, Al, “Ray Britt Becomes 4th Sea Bird To Enter
No Hitter in Book,” Jacksonville Journal, 1953.
Greater Beaches Stadium, Inc. stock
certificate. “Herky Payne Signs With Sea Birds.” newspaper photo, 1953.
Jacobson,
Steve. Carrying Jackie’s Torch: The
Players Who Integrated Baseball—And America. Chicago: Lawrence Hill Books, 2007. Terwilliger, Wayne, with Nancy Peterson, and Peter Boehm, Terwilliger Bunts One. Globe Pequot, 2006.
The Bird Brain [Vivian Ropon], “For The
Birds,” Column in Sea Bird Program. |
|
© 1990-2013 Donald J. Mabry / The Historical Text Archive Programmed By: Custom PHP Design
|